Wednesday, March 7, 2012

The Rockaway College Concept Paper: Introduction

The blog entry of February 16, 2012, started a process of posting my thoughts on a school start-up project, Rockaway College, meant to bring a different path to the formal education of the full spectrum of gifted and talented, most especially to the Twice-Exceptional.   To recall:  The purpose of this task is to place in an accessible space the details of the school project so when I outreach to the professional educators recruiting them to form the institution’s development, fundraising and start-up team I can refer them to a source presenting a thorough understanding of the nature of the school.  And, hopefully, having been inspired by what they read, the interested will sign-up and work as a team to translate the writing on the screen to brick and mortar.

So far, I’ve:
-told the story of how I discovered Democratic Education and of how my Democratic school project, Rockaway College, came to be,
-defined Democratic Education,
-concisely critiqued current schooling,
-argued that formal learning structured differently than the current means by which children are schooled would not allow the harm and the hurt of contemporary schooling, especially to those who do not fit into the narrow band suited to best work through the current schooling system, that the cultivation of Mindfulness and Empowerment in each child are the twin pillars of the altered schooling structure, that Democratic Education engenders Mindfulness and Empowerment and represents the altered schooling certainly capable of working for those not fitting into the current system,
-detailed the Democratic Education System and its Curriculum,
-identified a poorly served student population, The Gifted Talented Disabled, who would be well served by the Democratic Education of Rockaway College,
-argued for the need to attend to this population which also demonstrated the need for Rockaway College,
-showed how following the neurology of these youngsters, as would Rockaway College, meets psychological and educational needs of this population,
-began detailing the school itself with explains of the concepts informing the institution’s learning models,
-and, described the learning models used in Rockaway College.

The next series of entries, commencing with this one, will feature the core concept paper detailing the school.   

I. INTRODUCTION:
The purpose of this paper is to outline an integrated pre-school through early college institution providing the bright neuro-diverse, i.e., the spectrum of gifted and talented, in New York City, an education environment focused on emotional wellness and healing and on a supportive individual responsibility centered learning within a Cooperative School culture.  Indeed, living through the cooperative community culture and learning through their natural inclinations and unique differences children, adolescents and young adults supported in their efforts by deep mentoring relationships would take responsibility for deciding what they learn, when learning happens and how what is chosen is learned and would help each other set solid emotional foundations for future growth while assisting each other to uncover and to explore their native intelligence, enhance their learning skills, enrich their scholarship and cultivate a deep appreciation of the classical and the modern worlds. 

THE MISSION of Rockaway College, then, is to cultivate in all its students a solid psychological foundation for future growth and a cognitive dexterity for adaptability to life’s vicissitudes by providing a highly supportive Learner-Responsibility-Centered education.

The proposed institution of learning situates itself within two units, Rockaway College School and Rockaway College.   Rockaway College School would consist of a unified Pre-School and Kindergarten and of an Elementary School; Rockaway College would consist of a Venture School, a Lower School and an Upper School. 

Collectively the education programs of  The School and The College represent a sequential progression in emotional and intellectual development:   The unified Pre-School/Kindergarten develops the regulation of children’s social-emotional dispositions and cultivates their natural learning instincts through engagement with a toy enhanced Montessori prepared environment for ages 3 to 5.  The Primary Education Program of the Elementary School would integrate a Montessori prepared environment for ages 6-11, an inquiry freedom of an Open, Democratic Classroom and a cooperative norm based form of community governance.  An intake program for secondary education, The Venture School, would offer an outdoor personal growth experience within a cooperative norm based community governance.  The Lower and The Upper Schools like Bard High School Early College, in New York City, would combine secondary academic and junior college Liberal Arts education so upon graduation from the Upper School young scholars would receive both a high school diploma and an Associate of Arts degree. The Lower School would offer secondary education through subject discipline learning labs, thematic study, individual project based learning and performance assessment within a cooperative community governance while the Upper School would offer a Cooperative Learning seminar course structure within a cooperative norm based community governance.

The remainder of this paper describes the Student Population, Rockaway College School and Rockaway College.

Tuesday, March 6, 2012

The Learning Models of Rockaway College

Rockaway College design is premised on a special use of the general principles of Democratic Education.  It institutes a supported self-directed and negotiated learning for the spectrum of gifted and talended, but it is attending most to the needs of the Twice-Exceptional.  The College holds four learning levels, an early childhood, a primary, a secondary and an early college.  Each learning level structures itself according to a unique Democratic Education model of student knowledge acquisition.

As it turns out, Dr. Susan Baum has developed a highly compatible learner-decision-centered process for the student population of The College, the bright neuro-diverse, called Talent Development.  The College, quite naturally, infuses Talent Development in the Democratic Education learning models chosen for each learning level. 

Talent Development is derived from Dr. Baum’s research and practice demonstrating that when above average neuro-diverse youngsters concentrate on topics fitting their strengths and are not forced to engage academic achievement through weakness, they develop the self-confidence and skills allowing them schooling success, and to eventually, when ready, engage those areas which challenge weakness.  In Rockaway College, then, each student would be free to choose what to learn, when to learn what has been chosen and how to learn what has been chosen based on the individual’s cognitive strengths and innate compensated weaknesses, the individual’s Neuro-Learning Style; only when the youngster demonstrates a very positive self-image, borne from successful work through his and her Neuro-Learning Style, and only when the child feels the immediate need to move through an area of deficit would the student be encouraged to undertake learning through deficits.  And when learning through deficit is done, compensatory strategies would be first used and then remediation only if the child wishes to tackle deficit learning that way. 

With this in mind, the following can go on to explain the learning models used.  There are four models: Democratic Montessori with Toys, Democratic Montessori, Democratic Education and Democratic Education Within a Conventional College Semester Course Structure. 

Democratic Montessori with Toys is the learning model used in the early childhood program.  It combines Montessori’s prepared environment with Democratic Education’s intrinsic motivated learning.

Maria Montessori about 100 years ago in Italy observed how children learn.  She saw children striving to satisfy their immediate needs as motivating individual learning behavior.  She noticed in children what she called “sensitive periods”, those times when a child’s mind is more in need of acquiring a specific knowledge set than at others as constituting their immediate learning needs.  Additionally, she viewed very young children in learning environments constructed by adults of the time unable to grow children mentally or physically healthy:  These environments were looking to satisfying adult need, not child need.  Further, she well noticed how powerful and energetic natural curiosity was for learning, to the point where no adult need force a child to learn, especially during the sensitive periods.  From these observations, she developed her “Method”. 

The Method centers itself in adults preparing a learning environment for children to engage filled with material and activity calculated to resonate with each sensitive period.  In the Method adults do not tell children what to do beyond an initial permission to actively engage the material of the prepared environment.   They consciously observe how each child interacts with the materials and the activities ascertaining each child’s needs and if required altering the environment-the material and the activity-to put in the way of the child the elements to satisfy his and her needs.

Over the decades The Method has given rise to the production and use of specialized learning materials.  They are engineered for what is called “internal correction of error”, meaning that each Montessori Material when used right will correct any unintended learning to exactly and only that learning for which the material has been engineered.  In that way, the child learns what the adults think is appropriate to each sensitive period through the active experience of learning from the material, far and away the best method of learning, instead of having the adult telling the child exactly what the child is to learn, the worst way of learning, the worst way of trying to satisfy child need. 

Unfortunately, the highly structured one way learning forced by the “right” use of Montessori Materials works, like conventional schooling, to exercise convergent cognitive processes to the exclusion of the divergent ones, especially held by the intended student population of the early childhood and primary programs.   The Pink Tower is a fine illustration here:  The Pink Tower is comprised of a number of graduated sized foam blocks meant to be stacked in order from the largest on bottom to the smallest on top; it is also meant to fall over if constructed improperly; so, through trial and error a very young child will experience the connections among the block sizes until the idea is learned that size matters in relation of one to another as well as a practical lesson in gravity.  Now, when a child’s mind is largely convergent, this internal correction of error is quite natural and not harmful, but when a child’s mind is largely divergent, the correction of error in the Pink Tower, and in all other Montessori Materials, makes no sense as the child will do with the blocks, or other Materials, as the child’s divergent neurology compels trying to arrange and re-arrange to see how many different arrangements he/she can make.  Sad to say, too often, when a Montessori teacher sees a divergent thinking child working with a material differently than is intended, he/she will verbally correct the child to bring the child into doing the right thing with the material, which goes against the entire exercise of the adult role in The Method.  And, in the end, the child learns that he/she is not smart enough to learn on his/her own-that is called “learned helplessness”, something at which our conventional schooling excels.

We know the above average neuro-diverse are divergent thinkers.  Thus, to limit engagement of learning material to the “right” use of the Montessori Materials would not work to align the learning environment to the neurology of youngsters in both the early childhood and the primary programs.  Thus, the school’s teachers would grant youngsters, of course within safety guidelines, the permission to engage the engineered material based on their own proclivities allowing the intended learning to be discovered along with any unintended learning the material allows.  Additionally, with the importation of appropriate toys and play activities exercising the divergent processes into a Montessori Materialed prepared environment, students would be able to broaden their learning to that intrinsic to each toy and activity, providing further development of their natural divergent cognitive processes as well as enabling each child to take away the good feelings individual, independent experiential learning imparts, not to mention the mental wellness the power of self achieving its own goals engenders. 

Democratic Montessori is the learning model used in the Primary Education Program.  It stitches together Democratic Education and Montessori schooling by combining Montessori’s prepared environment with Democratic Education’s community governance and intrinsic motivated learning.

Democratic Education is the learning model used in the secondary and early college programs of Rockaway College (and is infused within the Montessori models of the early childhood and primary learning programs).  Democratic Education is defined as formal study controlled by the learner where the individual takes full responsibility for his and for her own course of learning and as schooling managed by the learning community collectively where the school body as a whole takes responsibility for governing itself.         

The Democratic Education system described earlier is given recapitulation here.  Democratic Education is driven by the individual social, emotional and cognitive needs of the students as manifested by them, not by an interpretation of them by the adults in the class rooms, indeed, where the child is the definer of his and her own need and the decision maker as to how to satisfy the felt need.  This goes against traditional adult over child power relation where the adult is the one to define child need and is the decision maker on how to meet the interpreted need with the result that a Democratic Education school would look quite different from what people have come to expect in schools. 

First, the course of study in Democratic Education over an entire school residency emerges unique to every child as each engages learning through his and her individual differences.  Children possess different neurological constructions, interests, abilities, temperaments, learning and communication styles and rates of emotional, cognitive and social development.  These natural instincts and individual differences drive learning tasks whether anyone likes it or not since that’s the biology of each youngster.  But the standardization of curriculum of the conventional setting, especially under the rubric of grade level standards, completely deny difference and in the end forces youngsters to work against their neurological constructions, interests, abilities, etc.  Indeed, the interventions and accommodations undertaken in the conventional setting attempt to remediate learning differences having as their goal every youngster socially, emotionally and cognitively enabled to place in ready recall memory the same content at the same time with approximately the same outcomes as every other child, thus, demanding youngsters to repress those elements of personality driving child need for different knowledge sets and for knowledge acquisition through distinctly different, biologically determined means resulting in the denial of those needs with the concomitant negative psychological impacts. 

Such differences in predispositions ought to be understood to drive differentiated knowledge seeking, acquisition and use yielding quality differentiated outcomes over a term and over the course of a school residency for each youngster.  Democratic Education being an authentic child learning self-directed system would put in the way of children the widest possible range of subject matter and let the children’s natural inclinations and differences drive what is learned, when it is learned and how what is chosen is learned.

However, unlike the Sudbury Valley model of self-directed learning which removes the adult from almost all of the child’s decisions, this model of self-directed learning used in Rockaway College fully acknowledges the need for a mentoring relationship of adult to child where an adult mentor and a youngster enter a process mutually respectful of the wisdom of each to attain a common understanding of and an agreement on learning goals and the action steps required to reach those goals; this includes a mentor working with children on social-emotional, psycho-dynamic and learning deficit issues.  The agreements on what is undertaken to be learned and when and how learning is to happen is known as a “negotiated curriculum” and is a fundamental part of this institution.

Second, in-school engagement within a child learning self-directed community of a negotiated and a self-selected curriculum during a Democratic Education school day would be through the student choice of one or more of three ways:  through independent, individual or small group engagement with the materials and activities open to students, through self-selected small, whole group adult facilitated topic study or activity and/or through self-initiated one-to-one instruction either with another student or with an adult.  In the authentically child-decision-centered learning environment of a Democratic Education school the initiation of learning engagement, including instruction, is up to the child, based on a felt need to connect with the knowledge, the materials, the activities, the adults and classmates, rather than the fully adult initiated whole group classroom process of the traditional taking all decisions away from the youngster.

Third, Democratic Education aligns its learning on the way children actually learn.  Youngsters learn through a slow process of inquiry where, by way of natural intuitive observation, they form extremely tentative hunches which are self-tested against experiences.  They continuously and unconsciously survey the consequences of their hunch testing, noticing regularities and patterns.  They begin to ask questions, to make deliberate experiments, sharpening their own awareness of the interplay of action, environment and results and in the process cultivate a reflexive and then an intentional self-regulation, within which there is a growing meta-cognitive process propelling intentional knowledge seeking and use.  Compelled by adults to constantly prove either they know or do not know youngsters stop trying to self-test, confirm and strengthen their faint hunches and give up. This is also the case when youngsters are compelled by adults to undertake objects of learning in which they have no interest or native inclination.  This learned helplessness debilitates during school days and well throughout a life-time.  Democratic Education constructs learning to advantage the way children actually learn empowering them to take responsibility for their own decisions in schooling and in life.

Fourth, Democratic Education elevates “learning to learn” well above content mastery. Content mastery focused learning cannot cultivate in youngsters the quick adaptability required of the wired life of the twenty-first century and beyond. Within an era of total social diffusion of information technologies and the information saturation these technologies’ have wrought, the ability or the desirability to store in one’s mind a set of Core Knowledge has become grossly irrelevant. Rather, the basic skills of learning itself, the abilities to define a question, to answer it and to articulately report what has been discovered through the skilled use of different media, additionally, to analyze the information according to the demands of the question, to synthesize the information with prior knowledge to create new knowledge to answer the question, to generalize the new knowledge and the process itself across other questions, are the keys preparing youngsters for the quick adaptability necessary for life today and in the future. And these learning to learn skill sets are taken by Democratic Education to be the principal objectives of its education. 

Fifth, emotional readiness to accept a learning task comes well before the task in a Democratic Education school. Any learning first depends on how a youngster feels about herself, empowered or powerless, competent or stupid. Compelling a task when someone feels powerless or stupid just frightens, discourages and deepens helplessness. Democratic Education environments concentrate on providing a time for emotional development first, when youngsters come to feel safe in trusting their native leaning instincts and their unique ways of knowing. As well, it provides those injured by their prior schooling, a time of healing, a time of taking off the pressure, of reassurance, as in time they will gain the energy and the courage to accept any task. 

Free and self-organized imaginative play is the readiness activity in Democratic Education. Youngsters engage in whatever play the environment supports for as long as they wish. Indeed, Democratic Education environments provide areas intended to stimulate imaginative play as well as individual and group physical play.  In Rockaway College’s early childhood and primary programs, along with the Montessori Materials there would other “stuff” like Lincoln Logs and blocks, toys and puzzles, sand and water tables, costumes and theatrical makeup, paints and crayons, newsprint and paper, hammers, nails, saws and wood, etc. There would be performance spaces and child friendly kitchens and appliances. There would also be indoor and outdoor playground equipment and open space. Even for the adolescents in the secondary program play can also be in wood or in metal or in performance with acting or music or in the arts with drawing, painting, sculpting. Or they too can take to the kitchen or the indoor/outdoor playground equipment and open space. Or, they can play in the outdoors, camping, hiking, backpacking, canoeing, rafting, skiing, biking, etc. Then, when in their own time they feel ready, each will engage in whatever formal learning is chosen.

Sixth, in Democratic Education formal learning is required to turn its attention to preparing youngsters for life itself, not for jobs or careers.  To have as the goal of formal learning the social utility of a disciplined, trained workforce is to give to education the conventional meaning which is a far too narrow, counter-productive and harmful one for 21st century America and which continues the dysfunction damaging to all youngsters and to the nation and the society. Schooling ought to be looking to the larger function of socialization, of providing the society and the nation with healthy citizens capable of making their own decisions.  Or to sum it up:  The goals of our intentional learning communities ought to be to cultivate in all youngsters a solid psychological foundation for future growth and a cognitive dexterity for adaptability to life’s vicissitudes.  Indeed, schooling should be about the healthy, happy growth in self-awareness, self-regulation and self-actualization.  In the end it’s all about taking care of the psychic side of life, for once that is healthy, the rest will follow in good order.  The 21st century and beyond need mentally healthy citizens who can leverage their good health in which ever way they discern is in their best interest and in the best interest of family, community, country and civilization. 

Seventh, the adults in the room of a child-decision-centered, child learning self-directed environment of a Democratic Education school have an additional role beyond being facilitators and mentors in self-directed and negotiated study:  They are to model life long learning, passionate engagement and the meanings of collaborative work, goal setting, task acceptance and completion by undertaking learning activities of interest to the adult, inviting youngsters as helpers, as apprentices, in what is being done rather than as “students” being told what to do, and to in equal measure with the children of the learning community maintain behavioral norms according to both individual child and whole community needs through The Democratic Process, peer mediation, Non-Violent Communication (https://www.cnvc.org/) and the LEAP process (http://leapinstitute.org/).  .   

And eighth, Democratic Education schools are self-governing, like Summerhill.  As A.S. Neill states:  “Summerhill is a self-governing school, democratic in form.  Everything connected with social, or group life…is settled by vote at the Saturday General School Meeting. Each member of the teaching staff and each child, regardless of his age, has one vote…Our democracy makes laws…[However,]…there are aspects of school life that do not come under the self-government regime.  My wife plans the arrangements for bedrooms, provides the menu, sends out and pays bills.  I appoint teachers and ask them to leave if I think they are not suitable. The function of Summerhill self-government is not only to make laws but to discuss social features of the community as well. (Alexander Sutherland Neill, Summerhill: A Radical Approach to Child Rearing, New York: Hart Pub. Co., 1960, pp 45-47.) 

In Democratic schools the community comes together in regular meetings of the whole community to decide issues open to community decision. Adults and children have equal rights to speak and to persuade within community forums. Each has a single vote on questions up for community decision. The community can decide policies on such as curriculum and assessment, projects and assignments, graduation requirements and ceremonies, expectant behaviors consistent and inconsistent with the norms of the school as well as the means by which inconsistent behaviors are resolved.

Democratic Education within a conventional college semester course structure is the learning model used in the early college.  It incorporates community decision-making entirely, but expresses individual learning decisions as participation within a cooperative course configuration rather than in independent topic study.

Monday, March 5, 2012

Concepts Informing Rockaway College Learning Models


Knowledge acquisition in Rockaway College is designed around a learner-decision-centered concept for the bright neuro-diverse, the spectrum of gifted and talented, called Talent Development.  Talent Development infuses the learning models employed for each school level, early childhood, primary, secondary and early college.  There are four unique models:  Democratic Montessori with Toys for early childhood, Democratic Montessori for primary, Democratic Education for secondary and Democratic Education within a conventional college semester course structure for early college.  These models formally express at the appropriate developmental stage the concepts explained herein.
     Children ought to be themselves:    All children are natural learners with different neurological construction, abilities, interests, temperaments, information receiving, processing and communicating styles and rates of emotional, cognitive and social development.  Healthy growth-mental and physical, emotional and intellectual-require formal learning environments to fully allow for the differences among children and permit them to grow in their own way and in their own time according to their own neurological construction, abilities, interests, etc. 

     Neurological Atypicality as exhibited in the Spectrum of Gifted and Talented is a synthesis of Strength and Weakness:  Here strength complements and compensates for weakness presenting a fusion pathway to learning, a blend inseparable and, thus, unamenable to divided treatment called the Neuro-Learning Style. Formal learning environments for the neurological atypical must fully support the whole child rather than divide and serve separate aspects of cognitive functioning. 

     Talent Development is the basis of Neurological Atypical Learning:  With Talent Development strength areas determine the course of learning, rather than the rough equality among cognitive processes derived through the combination of strength and remediated deficit.  Talent Development requires the emphasis on student differentiated learning and on quality differentiated outcomes rather than the demand for uniform general education curriculum study and outcomes, as each neurological atypical youngster brings to leaning different Neuro-Learning Styles which determine what is learned, when learning occurs and how learning happens for each youngster.  In Talent Development learning through deficit is a student's choice and comes well after self-esteem is assured as happens when learning is developed through strength first.  And when a youngster chooses to learn through weakness compensatory strategies are learned rather than the deficit being remediated.

     Emotional readiness to accept a task comes well before the task:  Any learning first depends on how a child feels about herself, empowered or powerless, competent or stupid.  Compelling a task when a child feels powerless or stupid just frightens, discourages and deepens helplessness.  Formal learning environments intended for the younger above average neurological atypical where there is a definite possibility of emotional disturbance must cultivate a balanced emotional disposition in each child as its primary education outcome.  And formal learning environments intended for the older above average neurological atypical where there is definite emotional disturbance must provide a time for emotional healing, a time of taking off the pressure, of reassurance, as in time these youngsters will gain the energy and the courage to accept any task.  

     Play as the activity of emotional wellness:  Children ought to engage in whatever play the environment supports for as long as they wish.  Play for the younger of this population would be the means to uncover natural leaning instincts, to avoid the pain of emotionally damaging experiences and to gain trust in their own way of knowing.  Play for the older of this population would be the means to recover their natural learning instincts, to recover from the pain of prior experiences and to regain trust in their own way of knowing.

     Children move from learning through impulse to learning though intention:  Children grow naturally from intuitive to conscious learners, from impulse to intention.  Very young children’s engagement with the world is through impulse rather than through conscious intention.  They discover the characteristics of the world and the relationships between and among people, places and things and themselves through an intuitive engagement with everything around them.  There is an absence of a thought through, goal oriented process devised prior to action; rather there exists an overwhelming presence of impulse as motivation to action, to decision making.  And the impulse is the expectant feeling of joy, of pleasure, an object or activity will give.

Children of about five or six years of age continue the process from their very young childhood engaging with whatever material causes good feelings, and not because on considered reflection the use of objects or the participation in an activity is “calculated” to yield a high degree of joy, and not at all of any deliberate decision to learn what is intrinsically there to learn.  Impulse to play, to feel good, that's the motivation. Yes, there is intention choosing what objects and activities to engage. And in that respect there exists in the child a rudimentary reflective decision making process.   But, conflicts over the choice of material or activity to engage is at the impulse level, two competing impulses, and the decision to choose one over another rests on feeling which would give the more pleasure.

By about age seven or eight, depending on the individual, there begins a transition from strictly impulse to conscious intention. The more frequently the child says to him/herself, hey this looks cool, and then reaches for whatever is the cool object or activity, or asks questions about things and goes searching for the answers, the more conscious decision-making happens; and the more conscious decision-making happens the deeper the learning is about self and relationships of self to the world and to others and of relationships among and between the things of the world.  And as the child grows into adolescence, and young adulthood the more frequent the practice of conscious decision-making the deeper the habit of goal oriented, self-directed learning and the deeper the habit of taking individual responsibility for self becomes.

     Learning through direct engagement with the stuff of the world:  All people, places and things possess intrinsic characteristics open to children’s learning.  Children take away through intuitive curiosity, at first, progressing later to conscious, focused intention, selected intrinsic aspects of the things of the world with which they engage.

     Academic learning is all about the student’s felt need to know:  Youngsters must feel the need to know academic skills and subject content before undertaking specific skill acquisition and subject study.  Motivation is first placed within each youngster; they must come to feel the need on their own.

     Responsible children grow into responsible adults: To cultivate a responsible adult requires giving responsibility to the adult when a child.  And giving responsibility to the child requires empowering the child to make substantive decisions on the individual choices in his and her education.

     Children ought to be free to choose:  Freedom to choose that which affects the child individually, that which is of interest, of passion, of felt need, is essential for only under this kind of freedom can the child grow in his/her natural way and in being responsible.

     Freedom to choose means doing what you feel you need to do, so long as it doesn’t interfere with the needs of others:  Between compelling a child to stop hitting classmates and compelling him to learn Geography lies the meaning of social restraint and individual learning responsibility.  Hitting classmates involves others, but learning Geography involves only the individual.   The community has the right to restrain the antisocial individual because he is interfering with the needs of others to be within a safe, caring and friendly society but the community has no right to compel an individual to learn Geography, for learning Geography is a matter for the responsibility of the individual and his/her felt need to learn Geography.  But when the child feels the need and freely chooses to study Geography he should be supported with all the highest quality assistance he is willing to accept.

     Supporting the learning independence of the bright neurological atypical must fully acknowledge the need for a mentoring relationship of adult to child where an adult mentor and a youngster enter a process mutually respectful of the wisdom of each to attain a common understanding of and an agreement on learning goals and the action steps required to reach those goals; this includes a mentor working with children on social-emotional, psycho-dynamic and learning deficit issues. 

     Compelling assessment of learning destroys learning:  Children learn through a slow process of inquiry where, by way of natural intuitive observation, they form extremely tentative hunches which are tested against experiences.  Hunches become a bit stronger each time children test one and have it confirmed by experience until the point where they will say with conviction that they know that such and such is true.  Children compelled to constantly prove either they know or do not know stop trying to confirm and to strengthen their faint hunches and just give up.  Nonetheless, when freely chosen, self-assessment and peer assessment as well as staff assessment of reports of learning are taken as valued tools in following and in demonstrating social, emotional and cognitive growth.

     Elevating “learning to learn” well above content mastery. Content mastery focused learning cannot cultivate in youngsters the quick adaptability required of the wired life of the twenty-first century and beyond. Within an era of total social diffusion of information technologies and the information saturation these technologies’ have wrought, the ability or the desirability to store in one’s brain a set of Core Knowledge has become grossly irrelevant. Rather, the basic skills of learning itself, the abilities to define a question, to identify needed information to satisfy the question, to locate where and how to access the required information, to analyze the information according to the demands of the question, to synthesize the information with prior knowledge, to create new knowledge to answer the question, then to generalize the new knowledge and the process itself across other questions, are the keys preparing youngsters for the quick adaptability necessary for life today and in the future. And these learning to learn skill sets ought to be taken by any modern learning environment to be the principal objectives of its education. 
 
      All forms of human expression are of equal weight: When neurology bars one form of symbolism another form takes it place.  Thus both discursive and presentation forms of symbolism ought to be available for use with weight given only to those forms best suited to the neurology of each child.

     Cooperative self-directed learning:  where mixed age children work together to exercise their distinctive interests and ways of knowing; where individual inquiry is accomplished through cooperative learning groups; where learning group members act together to achieve individual learning objectives; and where Cooperative Learning strategies are employed for whole group learning.

     Resource Rich Learning Environment:  The scope and breath of learning in an environment full of cooperative self-directed learners is limited only by the amount of resources available from which to learn.  To develop the widest scope and the deepest breath of knowledge of the world, especially of the learned world, a necessary objective for an academic oriented institution, requires substantial aggregation of learning materials from manipulatives to research caliber library.

     Integrated interdisciplinary content learning:  Focused thematic studies on aspects of subject content from the intersections of multiple disciplines. 

     School community self-governance:  Children cannot feel they are taking full responsibility for their learning decisions unless they feel ownership of their learning environment.  Ownership is derived through participation in learning community governance which determines policies on such as curriculum and instruction, projects and assignments, learning benchmarks and graduation requirements, ceremonies and social events, expectant behaviors consistent and inconsistent with the norms of the school as well as the means by which inconsistent behaviors are resolved.

Sunday, March 4, 2012

Following the Neurology Meets 2e Educational Needs


Rockaway College assumes Twice-Exceptionality as a synthesis of both giftedness/talentedness and cognitive/social-emotional deficit where strength compensates for weakness creating a unique and indivisible learning style.  It also fully acknowledges cognitive deficits will never be remediated to approach strength as innate neurological construction sets inelastic cognitive capacities even as children grow to maturity; however, the College recognizes that compensatory strategies can work together with strengths to achieve tasks.  The College additionally assumes the individual neuro-learning style of each child will emerge as an intrinsic motivation toward different aspects of learning content and skills, establishing quality differentiated outcomes for the different neuro-learning styles. 

Thus, Rockaway College follows the neurology of children in the way Susan Baum follows the Talent (To Be Gifted and Learning Disabled: Strategies for Helping Bright Students with LD, ADHD, and More, 2004), in the way Thomas Armstrong follows the gifts (Neurodiversity: Discovering the Extraordinary Gifts of Autism, ADHD, Dyslexia and Other Brain Differences, 2010), in the way Stanley Greenspan follows the autistic child’s abilities in Floortime (The Floortime Approach to Helping Children Relate, Communicate and Think, 2003), in the way Maria Montessori follows children’s sensitive periods (The Secret of Childhood,1966).  

Following the individual neuro-learning style will satisfy the 2e need:
• to develop cognitive and social-emotional growth in subject and affective areas according to individual differences and pace
• to cultivate compensatory strategies for deficits complimenting talent development
• to possess high self-esteem
• to exercise a high degree of self-direction
• to form and employ their heightened curiosity and questioning
• to engage a wide range of interests
• as well as to connect with a specific talent or consuming interest area for which they have an exceptional memory and knowledge
• to effect high levels of problem-solving and reasoning skills leading to penetrating insights, advanced ideas and opinions which they will be encouraged to express
• to think divergently
• to apply a heightened creativity and imagination in approach to tasks
• to foster an outstanding vocabulary and a superior verbal expression
• to nurture expressive capacities across neuro-compatible media.

In other words, Rockaway College’s approach to learning in following the neuro-learning style to quality differentiate outcomes will satisfy the Twice-Exceptional need to individually acquire the knowledge and skills enabling each in their own way/in their own time to be next schooling level or career ready upon graduation and will satisfy their collective need to have developed the Mindfulness and the Empowerment to take full responsibility for the course of their lives.

The Need to Attend to the Twice-Exceptional-The Need for Rockaway College

The case studies of Charlie, David and Jonathan, told last post, form a portrait of the existence of the Twice-Exceptional and of the complete failure of our current schooling to meet their needs.  Rockaway College would provide a growth medium for the full spectrum of Gifted and Talented but would focus its learning programs on direct service to the Twice-Exceptional providing these children an altered schooling structure making it impossible for the problems of conventional schooling to take root and giving those hurt by their prior schooling a place to heal.

Demonstrating a need to serve the Twice-Exceptional and for Rockaway College centers in two areas:  1) complete absence of identification against there being a sizable number of 2e children creating a huge gap in education for this population,  and 2) inappropriate intervention strategies failing the needs of 2e children.

1) There is a total absence of identification of this population against there being a sizable number of 2e children creating a huge gap in education for this population.  In the State of New York a child can be found to be disabled or gifted/talented not both:  Neither Article 89, Title 6, of New York State Education Law, governing Special Education, or Article 90, Title 6, of New York State Education Law, governing Gifted and Talented Education, specify the presence of the Twice-Exceptional.  Thus, without the necessity of local school districts to identify, local school authorities have excluded Twice-Exceptional children in reporting their student populations, making prevalence unknown throughout the State, and in New York City as well. (Bills S.1273 and A5507, currently in respective Education Committees of the State Legislature are meant to remedy this.) 

Yet, as the Colorado Department of Education points out in its Introductory Resource Book, “Twice-Exceptional Students:  Gifted Students with Disabilities”, “…2-5 percent of the gifted population will have disabilities and 2-5 percent of students with disabilities will be gifted.” (p. 15).  Thus, those looking for prevalence in New York City, especially, must extrapolate based on current numbers of gifted and of disabled served by City Public Schools for the public schools hold hard numbers, the private school's do not.  Admittedly this method will undercount prevalence, but presently it is the only way to have any useful data.

New York City defines giftedness as those scoring within the top 10th percentile on admissions tests, which de facto excludes children with disabilities who do poorly on these assessments; thus, regardless of the number of “gifted” served in the City schools, calculation of probable 2e population from the gifted population is impossible.

But, as the National Education Association points out in their manual, “The Twice Exceptional Dilemma” (2006), disabilities cover gifts.  Thus, it is possible to extrapolate a reasonable number of Twice-Exceptional from the number of students the City has declared as disabled.  According to the Public Advocate, the City is educating 210,000 disabled youngsters. (Public Advocate DeBlasio and ARISE Coalition Kick Off ‘Students with Disabilities Month’, April 3, 2011)  Therefore, taking two to five percent of 210,000 gives an estimate of a minimum pool of 4,200 to 10, 500 youngsters.  Now, Micaela Bracamonte, Director and Founder of the only school in New York City dedicated to educating the Twice-Exceptional, calculates a figure of 50,000 for New York City (“Twice-Exceptional Students:  Who Are They and What Do They Need”, p. 4) .  Further, according to Marlo Payne Thurman, “My colleagues and I agree that gifted children with disabilities occur in much more…of the gifted population, as commonly believed in the past.  In fact, twice-exceptionality may be closer to the norm than the exception in gifted populations.” (Marlo Payne Thurman, “Too Tired!  Energy and Wellness in 2e Children”, 2e Newsletter, Issue 38, January/February 2010, p. 16.)

Regardless of the numbers chosen, they represent a rather sizable population of New York City youngsters in need of a learning environment dedicated to their unique needs.  And at this point, as mentioned, there is only one school, The Lang School, which is so dedicated, leaving a huge gap to be filled.

2) Inappropriate intervention strategies fail the needs of 2e children:  Educators, parents, and students are asked to choose between services to address one exceptionality or the other, according to the NEA’s manual.  Acceleration and Enrichment are the gifted services.  The Continuum of Services is the disability services.  Neither intervention strategy works to fulfill the needs of the Twice-Exceptional, as concentration on the gifts ignores the disabilities, and the concentration on the disabilities ignores the gifts.

Acceleration within current schooling is of state learning standard content:  it is more of the same just faster.   This cannot account for the pronounced asymmetrical growth typical of the Twice-Exceptional, not to mention the denial of other characteristics such as auditory and/or visual processing problems which may cause them to respond slowly, to work slowly, and to appear to think slowly, or motor difficulties exhibited by clumsiness, poor handwriting, or problems completing paper-and-pencil tasks, or the apparent lack of organizational and study skills-often appearing to be extremely “messy”, among others.  Enrichment is the imposition on the gifted of what is thought by teachers and other school officials to be of interest which cannot account for the high degree of self-direction possessed by the Twice-Exceptional, not to mention the denial of other characteristics such as a wide range of interests unrelated to enrichment topics, or a specific talent or consuming interest area for which they have an exceptional memory and knowledge, or advanced ideas and opinions which they are uninhibited in expressing, among others.

However, most problematic for the Twice-Exceptional is the disability intervention, the Continuum of Services.  It completely excludes the gifted element in favor of remediation of deficit.  Remediation applies various strategies to enhance cognitive weakness so a deficit area works roughly equal to the same cognitive area in non-disabled peers. Remediation, then, attempts to reverse and repair a child’s neurological or physical functioning for the purposes of maintaining students in the general education setting and of supporting the expected achievement of grade level learning standards.  Indeed, as Garth Harries put it:  “For…students with disabilities, the objective of special education is to enable them to learn the same content at the same pace as their non-disabled peers.” (Memorandum Regarding Recommendations to Improve Services to Students with Disabilities, July 2, 2009, pp. 7-8)

The results of the Continuum of Services/Remediation approach for regular special needs are summed up:
• Graduation statistics for the class of 2009 show that only 1 in 4 [25% of] students with disabilities graduated from high school in 4 years.
• Data just released by New York State education officials calculates that just under 17%
of students with disabilities in New York State graduate high school college and career
ready.
 (Out of School and Unprepared, Arise Coalition, February 2011, p. 2)

Clearly, since the regular special needs are being failed by current disability education in New York City, it is not much of a logical extension to say the Twice-Exceptional are as well.  And this failure of the system is compounded for the Twice-Exceptional in special education by the unrecognized and unserved gifted component.

Therefore, regardless of the current intervention, for giftedness or for disability, the needs of the Twice-Exceptional are never met.

Thursday, March 1, 2012

The Gifted Talented Disabled “Tail Ends” of the Curve

“…the profoundly negative consequences of forcing children to function in systems designed for adult convenience and adult notions of adult-child relationship rather than children’s needs can be seen in our schools everyday, and are most severe for children at the “tail ends” of the curve (those who are gifted…and gifted children who also have disabilities).”   The education field refers to the gifted and talented children with disabilities as Twice-Exceptional (2e) or Gifted Talented Learning Disabled (GTLD).

Democratic Education can work for most children.  But, as anyone who has read any of this blog well knows my son should have been identified and served as Twice-Exceptional, wasn’t, and developed pathologies leading him to be driven literally mad.   Once I became educated to education I searched for the kind of formal learning environment where he would have thrived.  I discovered Democratic Education and almost from the beginning I saw this exceptional idea as most suitable.  Now, I cannot help my son, but I hope to be able to help other Twice-Exceptional sons and daughters through this means of formal education.

Twice-Exceptionality is characterized by extremes of ability and disability within a single child leading to discrepant development in social, emotional and cognitive aspects of personality.  Thus, a child may be beyond his age and grade level performance in school subject matter, such as Math, while socially-emotionally more immature than age or grade level expectations. Or a child may be well beyond age and grade level standards in a subject or two but severely lagging in others, say, well ahead in Reading but well behind in Math.  Or a child may present as brilliant but achieve poorly, or a child may present as brilliant, achieve well but develop emotional disturbances and mal-adaptive coping mechanisms.  Or, a child may have absolutely no interest in school subjects at all and thus achieve poorly and be disruptive, but be well read and informed in depth on topics of personal interest.  Regardless of how 2e children present, their  identification as part of student populations, their social, emotional and cognitive needs being understood and the ability of the school setting to meet their individual needs are crucial in developing  a healthy life time growth in these children and are vital to their success in our society.

The Twice-Exceptional are in every school and in every classroom.  The following case studies form a portrait of their existence, and of the complete failure of our current schooling to identify children in this population, to understand their individual needs and to construct learning structures meeting those needs.  More, the forced uniformity of standardization and accountability over time develop pathologies leading to self-destructive behaviors. 

(Sensitivity to the feelings of the children and their families requires the anonymity of these students whose case studies are related here. Nonetheless, be assured that the author of this blog post has worked with these youngsters as an educator discharging his professional duties.)

Charlie was a bright, smiley fourth grader.  He was highly verbal, having a working vocabulary well above his age and grade. Every day he would engage teachers, especially, in conversation about many things, but he had one subject of great interest, baseball. In fact, he would talk baseball stats, game situations and strategies and individual player and team performances through history even in the middle of winter when everyone else was in basketball mode. However, it didn’t take long for teachers to understand that while his interest in the sport was genuine and deep, as his interest in talking with them, he was respectfully changing the subject.  Whenever a teacher would request he be about doing his school work he would engage the adult with his baseball talk.  And when finally he saw he couldn’t talk anymore he would do something else, something definitely not school work.

For Charlie the problems were about being made to read dump stories about silly people doing silly things-that was the way he stated complaints about English Language Arts.  He complained likewise about being made to do stupid games, “like” cross word puzzles or matching columns, about being made to do endless boring math problems.   He had a long list of complaints about “being made to” and all using the epithets, stupid, silly and boring.

He said at one time, all he wanted was to be in a place which “made sense”.  At his tender age he couldn’t get beyond that slogan.  But he knew being forced to expend his energies doing “stupid” and “silly” nonsense was a waste of time. Yet, in the uniform school the only way Charlie could express his being out of place was to be non-compliant.  Countless numbers of times was he escorted to the Principle’s office by one teacher or another.  Indeed, the more discipline these folks brought down on this youngster the greater his non-compliance.  The amazing thing about Charlie during the early grades was in his ability to keep his anger in check.  No matter the provocation, he would remain polite, non-compliant but respectful.  However, this lad did not keep that balance.  Being out of place with no alternative available continued to exert an ever greater cost:  eventually, in seventh grade he turned mean.

David was a brilliant and restless seventh grader.   He loved to talk with anyone, especially teachers, who would oblige.  But his level of discourse ranging over history, politics, popular culture, was so adult-like that his classmates, and more than a few teachers, couldn’t keep up.  David brought a joyous energy to his conversations. The disturbing fact was that most of the time when he was exercising his joyously energy teachers were instructing him and his class.  Shortly after the period started, he would rise from his seat and slowly tour the classroom making his way in a grand circular fashion.  He would stop to stare out a window but for only a moment, then he was on the move, again.  He would engage both classmates and teachers in conversation during these sojourns.  He chatted outside the classroom, but unfortunately his favorite moment for conversation was about ten minutes into a lesson.

When he saw he couldn’t stop instruction he would quietly leave the classroom, always without permission.  He roamed the halls landing in either the computer lab or the library.  There he would make himself busy with whatever he chose.  Interestingly enough he was quiet and well behaved disturbing no one in these settings.  He would return a minute before the bell rang to collect his belongings.

David had Disgraphia, an inability to write by hand.  His hand writing was painfully slow.  And with a mind as fast as his, his inability to hand write created great frustration.  But, he had developed an aural compensation so all he had to do was listen for a minute to know the intent of instruction for the period, and his genius allowed him to quickly learn the content of that lesson without having to sit through all the teacher talk about it.  As it turned out no one took seriously his troubled hand writing because there is this crazy notion in some of the education profession which believes that if you’re highly intelligent you have no problems as problems come only to those far less gifted.

David continued his antics in the eighth grade but his genius did little to protect him when it came to the eighth grade state tests which he passed, barely, and protected him no longer as he moved into the uniform high school where daily full period attendance and serious pen and paper testing trumped the way he learned and reported learning. David in the middle of ninth grade was on the verge of either dropping out or of being severely punished for his continued avoidance of being in the classroom and for his continued inability to write by hand. 

Jonathan demonstrated a fine artist’s right brain advantage.  He sketched with keen eye and hand even when he was doodling.  He also had a great ear, and passion, for music and played a mean guitar. He was a brilliant high school junior but he had been placed in a special education class since his 9th grade year because the administrators of his high school couldn’t figure out what to do with him.  Everyone agreed he was very bright.  But his long purple hair, his black, Johnny Cash wardrobe, and his penchant for being non-compliant and non-conforming demonstrated to these folks an outright defiance of the uniform school and an adolescent in need of discipline which he was on many occasions. 

He would sit in class sullen, disinterested, and at times a bit high.  He would sketch rather than pay attention to instruction.  Even when his teacher would try a one to one instruction he, politely, played dumb.  His grades were barely passable.  Sometimes he would absent himself from school for days.  But the police brought him back every time.  So, he stayed stubbornly a rebellious artist in opposition to being told to be otherwise even though he had been repeatedly threatened by the school’s Principal and Vice-Principal with all sorts of hell and damnation.

One day in the school parking lot, Jonathan was caught smoking a marijuana joint, arrested and thrown in jail for five years.

Twice-Exceptional children exist, but schools, public and private, ignore them to the extreme detriment to the children’s mental health and to their social productive capacities. 

Rockaway College’s special use of the general principles of Democratic Education would provide these children an altered schooling structure making it impossible for the problems of conventional schooling to take root and giving those hurt by their prior schooling a place to heal.

Tuesday, February 28, 2012

Democratic Education Curriculum and Summation

(Author’s Note:  Christopher Quirk, Director of Easton County Day School, graciously allowed me to work closely with him on a proposal for a sustainable education community.  Part of this collaboration centered on a K-12 school.  This final exposition was a culmination of that collaboration in January, 2012.)

Democratic Education resets the conventional schooling structure and the relationships of adult to curriculum, child to curriculum and adult to child to where what is learned, when learning happens and how what is chosen to be learned is both child self-directed and adult-child negotiated.

In the conventional structure what is learned, the curriculum, is broken down into compartmentalized disciplines which are further broken down into subjects which themselves are divided into units which again are divided into smaller accumulations of specific facts and concepts available for the learner to take up into ready recall memory.  A basic outline of disciplines is as follows:
-English Language Arts
-Mathematics
-Social Studies
-Sciences
-Unified Arts (a sort of catch all for everything not included above)

The sociology of knowledge as discipline division is an inheritance of the specialization and expansion in knowledge from the late Middle Age European Classical grammar school trivium and the university quadrivium.  Indeed, the growth in the complexity of the sociology of knowledge under the agency of print dramatically increased information circulation, popular understanding and intellectual discovery requiring ever more differentiation of knowledge into distinct disciplines which were taken by generations of school folks as the basis for general study, preparing the young for a world where such knowledge was supposedly required.

However with the growth and societal saturation of electronic information technologies, three distinct effects must be recognized:  1) that the pace of information production exploded to the point where it is no longer possible, even if it were in times past, to hold the resulting amounts of information in memory; 2) that the need to hold information in human memory has been eliminated as these vast amounts are now stored in immediate access, digital memory; and 3) that the connectivity of digital media has broken down discipline barriers to recombine specialized knowledge at intersecting points.

Thus, it makes far more sense today for school folks to provide learning experiences whereby children can master learning rather than to master content, and what content is offered should take full notice of the recombination of specialized knowledge. 

To acquire learning skills in a child-decision-centered environment of a Democratic Education school is to provide a wide range of opportunities for children to engage using their native instincts and individual differences, their intrinsic motivation and self-efficacy, slowly gaining the skills as they test hunches/hypotheses, as they explore, discover and unfold, as they bring to consciousness through meta-cognitive development the mindfulness necessary for intentional learning decision making. 

It would begin with the readiness to acquire learning skills as the objective of an early childhood program while the acquisition of learning skills would be the focus of the elementary.  The mastery of learning would be the province of a secondary education.

To take full notice of the recombination of specialized knowledge is to provide an integrated, interdisciplinary thematic curriculum which at the macro-level can be ordered through Curriculum Strands, such as:
     -The Life Cycle in the Natural World
     -Communication Between Individuals and Within Groups
     -Identity Within Groups and Institutions
     -The Nature of Time and Space
     -Our Response to the Aesthetic
     -Our Relationship to Nature
     -Our Role as Producers and Consumers
     -Our Efforts to Live with Purpose.

Broken down into theme categories the curriculum strand of The Life Cycle in the Natural World, for instance, might include Ecology.  And the category Ecology itself can be broken down into themes such as:  Geography-life’s web of place and climate, and their affects on the development of plants, animals and people; Change-evolution and extinction, natural and man-made; Conservation-soil, air, water, energy; Micro and Macro Environments-explorations of the smallest and the largest ecosystems.  The curriculum strands and their theme categories and individual themes constitute the structural framework of the intentional learning community’s curriculum which the school constructors and governors are obliged to populate richly with resources and activities in order to  provide the knowledge sets open to child self-directed and negotiated learning.

The curriculum strands, as suggested above, would supply the knowledge categories youngsters engage in the abstract and in the experiential.  So, as a further example, within the curriculum strand of Our Relationship to Nature might be the theme category of Bugs and Other Creepy Crawly Creatures-explorations into insects and the role they play in ecosystems-whereby those exploring the theme could select a few square feet of property, describe the micro-ecosystem there, observe and note over a certain period all insects in the air column over the property, the creepy crawlers on and around the ground and under the surface to approximately 18 inches.  Then they would investigate to uncover the roles within that micro-ecosystem the creepy crawlers and flying insects have.  Having noted the findings, a report in a medium of choice would be produced and presented.  And on to the next theme, the next inquiry and on the education in this manner goes.

In summary, then, an altered schooling structure that would make it impossible for the problems of conventional schooling to take root is defined:
     -by the mission to cultivate in all youngsters a solid psychological foundation for future growth and a cognitive dexterity for life long adaptability to life’s vicissitudes:  the healthy, happy growth in self-awareness, self-regulation and self-actualization so in this century and beyond mentally healthy citizens can leverage their good health in which ever way they discern is in their best interest and in the best interest of family, community, country and civilization;
     -by the twin pillars of Mindfulness and Empowerment supporting the mental wellness and cognitive flexibility mission emerging within each youngster as a consistent response to the learning environment rather than through compliance demanded of children by the adults in the class rooms;
     -by a realigned relationship of adult to child from adult over child to adult and child partnering each respectful of and acting on the wisdom each possess;
     - by the emergence and recognition of individual social, emotional and cognitive needs of youngsters as manifested and self-identified by them, not by an interpretation of child behavior by the adults in the class rooms, indeed, where the child is the definer of his and her own need and the decision maker as to how to satisfy the felt need, and where through a mentoring relationship based on the mutual respect for wisdoms of each the child will be helped to help him-herself to satisfy the full range of need;
     -by an altered relationship of adult to curriculum and child to curriculum where what is learned, when learning happens and how what is chosen to be learned is both child self-directed and adult-child negotiated;
     -by knowledge acquisition being child decision driven through an individual’s neurological constructions, interests, abilities, temperaments, learning and communication styles and rates of emotional, cognitive and social development individualizing curricula and yielding quality differentiated outcomes;
     -by occasioning learning experiences whereby children can master learning rather than to master content, and what content is offered takes full notice of the recombining of specialized knowledge through an integrated, interdisciplinary, thematic curriculum;
     -by the school being community self-governed.

Rockaway College is an altered school concept so defined.