Monday, May 18, 2015

Consequences of Misjudging a Life


Papers, books, hand tools, thumb tacks, screws, plant hankers, drinking classes, sewing notions, clothes, shoes and other stuff here and here and here, all over the house, in fact...There are times when the stuff around our small house gets so high and scattered that it drives me to actually do a bit of straightening up. Neatly stacked piles, my mother used to say, is the perfect definition of straightening up; and I was always-well, almost always-an obedient son. So, I made a bunch of neatly stacked piles out of the chaos last week. In gathering a bunch of papers together I came across a couple of them I remember composing in early 2007 (yes, they were hanging around that long!).



I had just come off another episode of sticking to my well honed teaching principles. The professional acumen developed over the preceding twenty-six years got me in trouble with several students who complained to some folks in administration who called me on the carpet for using the principles I favored. For behaving as a professional educator, for being so calmly articulate in the defense of my practice and for having the audacity of pointing to the defects in the pedagogy and course design they were demanding I use, I was refused further teaching at this college. This was not the first and if I were ever to continue in higher education I doubt it would be the last. So, I was thinking about forever leaving The Academy for something else. A career counselor I consulted suggested I write down what I considered the most congenial working conditions and what kind of life I thought I was leading and wanted to live as conversation starters leading to the types of employment I could expect would best work for me.



I placed the most congenial working conditions in seven points (which I will list without comment):

  1. The work must intrinsically hold elevated levels of intellectual stimulation.
  2. There must be high frequency of professional and social conversation.
  3. The job should allow for creative communication through a single medium or through many media.
  4. The position must have sufficient autonomy for me to do what I think is professionally correct.
  5. The employer must highly value shared commitments where my commitment to the firm is shared equally with commitment to family and to community.
  6. The employer must highly value reciprocal commitments where a firm reciprocates my commitment to its mission by its commitment to my professional development, advancement, compensation and longevity.
  7. My job performance must be evaluated on how and what I am doing and the results produced rather than on mere compliance to a supervisor or a manager.



However, it is the life statement which is of far greater importance for it sums-up a dilemma enormously affecting my entire now forty-eight year adult existence.



I wrote:

“I've wanted to live a principled life. From a child's eye, I saw both my mother and my father as principled people. I have been formed and informed by my consistent perception of their principled actions founded in Forgiveness, Courage, Honesty, Integrity, Joyfulness, Compassion, Kindness, Commitment, Consideration, Creativity, Respect, Dignity, Enthusiasm, Morality, Justice, Fairness, Generosity, Gentleness, Patience, Graciousness, Helpfulness, Hopefulness, Humility , Idealism, Love, Purposefulness, Responsibility, Gratitude, Tolerance, Trust, Understanding, Wonder and Wisdom. As a consequence, I have developed a keen sense of right and wrong, of ways of being and ways of working best situated to help others help themselves. I have also cultivated insight into the fitness of structures within which people live, work, and play having the best opportunity to gain peace, love and understanding within themselves and with others and to acquire virtuous lives they themselves wish to cultivate and virtuous lives organizations say participation should develop.



And the reality of life since high school, some forty-one years [at the time of writing this statement] is that I have lived the principled life I wanted. However, keeping the faith of principle has put me at odds with 'the real world' where people, organizations and structures force decisions counter with the consequence that when given conventional parameters of living a successful live, I must say I am a definite failure.



Indeed, the parameters of life I've taken as the goals and measures of success, and, thus, of self-worth, are not those of a principled life but exclusively monetary/employment based, i.e., sustained professional employment and advancement with an upward slopping compensation and a substantial retirement nest egg. They have been given me by the communities within which I have lived, the society at large, and yes, my father-insisting out of deep love that I must be solidly on a permanent career path by age twenty-three else I will be a failure the rest of my life. But, with a deep rooted inability to reject or modify principle in favor of having to make a living subservient to wrong headed supervisors, adversely working organizations and destructive structures and with having the freedom to do so provided by a supportive family, I have a record of sporadic employment, barely any income and no contributions to a nest egg. In other words, by these standards, I am a failure as a human being and as long as I live failure will be a constant companion. No wonder I have always had a sense of being worthless!



But, I want to embrace the way I am, committing fully to a principled life, releasing the power to act accordingly without self-censure. To do so I need to somehow re-frame emotional anchors allowing me to switch from my community's imprint, the society's expectations and my father's demands to a self-acceptance, a self-love, of a who I am. Simultaneously, I need to develop and interiorize the goals and measures appropriate for my principled life. ”



Indeed, the crushing shame of worthlessness brought about by my own misjudging of my life through the years has resulted in a pattern of depression compelling me to withdraw within the four walls of whatever house I am in. More, I self-medicate with food over-eating so much that at one point decades ago I blew up to three hundred pounds. I once described the pattern as: feeling so worthless I hide in the house overeating, gaining a good deal of body weight which re-enforces being worthless...eventually after months have passed, I get up off the floor working through the self-hatred eating less and losing weight...after dropping a bunch of weight I feel capable enough to go out of the house...the more I go out, the more I am propelled to look for work, mostly teaching work...eventually I land an appointment...I do what I know to be professionally right, proper and necessary for the mental well being and the intellectual and the academic growth of the students I am given regardless of organizational imperatives, supervisory dictates or falling in line with what other teachers are doing...by standing on professional and personal principle I upset the expectations of a few students who complain to supervision...supervision is upset at me for being uncompliant with their wrongheaded methods and for upsetting the paying customers ...supervision, then, does not renew my appointment sending me out onto the street...I feel a failure, retreat to the four walls of whatever house I am in, self-medicate, gain weight, eat more, gain more, fell more useless...then months later I get off the floor working through the feelings of worthlessness, lose weight, feel capable enough to go out of the house, and so on.



When I wrote the life statement I had retreated into the house, began to overeat, started to gain back weight lost in the last round. However, writing the summary brought to the fore hazy thoughts on the matter I had been having. Indeed, writing it down clarified the dilemma under which I had been working all my adult life: a deep desire to live a principled life yet measuring life success and self-worth with grossly inappropriate criteria, ultimately misjudging my life entirely. Having gained the insight, I began to work through the bad feelings, ate less, went out of the house, engaged the community and gained teaching opportunities, which, I'm afraid ended the same as others. Unfortunately, I had yet to translate insight into a re-framed emotional predisposition, an altered psycho-dynamic, putting myself back into depressions with all its attending pathologies.


Intellectually I have placed my life in the proper perspective as a principled person. But, l continue to struggle greatly to re-set the emotional predispositions, my psycho-dynamic, to feel the power of a life so lived, to be not disturbed by irrelevant criteria of success, to fear no longer any judgment of others, or myself, of a failed life based on monetary/employment criteria. It has become quite obvious to me that this struggle will continue the rest of my life.

Tuesday, May 5, 2015

Here we go having come out of the dark tunnel again

Well, here we go again after nearly a year's absence.  I had a schedule of publishing twice a week thinking that would offer me a sufficient frequency to sustain a diet of blogging while allowing suitable reflective time for me to figure out what to say and how to say it.  Yes, twice a week did allow suitable reflective time, but the depression under which way too many things become impossible weighed too heavily on me for me to develop even the occasional diarist's habit.



And while I would like to thing that the unfortunate experience of my semester teaching at Fordham University was no big deal, I must acknowledge it plunged me into a psychological paralysis.  The fact that I was able to continue to listen to my favorite music radio station,  Fordham's public  radio WFUV-FM, largely ree from anger and self-loathing says a little something about the paralysis being not rock-bottom deep.  Still...It has seemed to me that other college professors get to have sufficient leeway in how they conduct their courses, but not me. 


I posted an open letter to my colleagues in the Media Ecology Association on the association's listserve on December 19, 2013 , being it was through connections there I landed the course at Fordham and to whom I thought to complain.  I enter it here to let others know.


"It happened yet again:  As usual, the instructional order, learning objectives, pedagogy and assessment of the course I was given to teach this concluding semester were premised on judgment developed from nearly forty years cultivating the deepest understanding of Human and Hard Tech Communication processes and affects on individuals, cultures and societies through time from both a “George Gerbner-U of Penn Annenberg-ICA” and a “Nystrom-Postman-Moran-NYU Media Ecology-MEA” perspective and of learning theory, pedagogy, practice and experience in Experiential Learning, Cooperative Learning, Socratic Method and Developmental Lesson Planning across levels of schooling from junior high to college, especially the collegiate. Well, as happens, the exercise of professional judgment upset a small number of young adults who had difficulty adjusting to my course construction and who complained up the chain of command to the effect that I was called on the carpet for exercising this acumen and required to implement a “course correction” in the methods and the substance of the course I was given to instruct.  


(This is a farewell message. For those who think it improper to be posted on the list, then, please, stop reading, now. All others I encourage to continue.)

David Linton, when working for him at Marymount Manhattan, said I possessed an articulate rebelliousness. While that, indeed, flattered my profound desire to see and to project myself aligned with the great Irish rebels and the equally great European and American tradition of free thinkers and non-conformists, the reality is that all I am about is putting in the service of good learning the pedagogical practices of Experiential Learning, Cooperative Learning, Socratic Method and Developmental Lesson Planning. More, I import the personal responsibility component from Democratic Education starting the movement in students away from the learned helplessness of the elementary-high school years to a self-actualization of the collegiate, from the infantilization of conventional primary and secondary teaching/learning toward the empowered adult of whole cognitive developed higher education. So, yes, David, I have ends in mind other than the specific content mastery of the course.
 
If there is anything authentically different from conventional exercise in these education strategies is that I employ them within the same course and, frequently, within the same class period giving students an array of means by which to acquire the content of the course and providing students an authentic responsibility to accept or reject the conditions of inclusion in each class and in the course along with the consequences of their decisions. I take as given that this is the first exposure to these methods and to these conditions for students and I fully recognize the adjustment difficulty visited upon them, especially on those holding expectations that they will be doing the same thing they have been doing from almost all of their schooling lives; thus, I incorporate personal support into each course prominently among which is individual one on one instructional/counseling sessions during and outside office hours.
 
David, this time around, I did not get the chance to be articulate. In fact, what was student complaint was given validation by all supervision without even a cursory chat with me to ascertain its authenticity. It is clear that there may be academic freedom for others but not for me. So, that’s it: stick a fork in me and pop me out of the oven, I’m done. I have always done the best for each young adult I was given the privilege of teaching, even those who complain. But, the conditions of employment whereby I am forbidden to use my professional judgment, and where I am being forced to employ pedagogical methods which even the schools in which I’ve taught hold workshops and seminars to get faculty to greatly move away from, have become intolerable. If being rebellious means I will not accept having to implement the least effective pedagogy just to stay employed as an adjunct, just to not upset, not to differently cognitively challenge, any student then, I am a rebel. Unfortunately, the consequence of being a rebel is to be marginalized and equally to marginalize oneself. So, on the margins of education I am to return. However, I can no longer afford to be there.
I am stepping away from the field of education completely as there truly is nowhere for me to be. I am also leaving the MEA, although I take with me the deepest knowing of how the world works. I want to thank all in the MEA who continue to believe I have an insightful thing or two to say and who in one way or another have acknowledged that over the years, especially those convention conveners who accepted my panels and those who graciously accepted inclusion. I wish everyone all the best. From now on if anyone wishes to reply to this or to keep in touch, please use ljfayhee@gmail.com.

As “an old friend use to say”, Good Night and Good Luck."

I'm still not done with education as the many successive blog posts here will attest.  But, unless something of a miracle happens I doubt very much that I will see the inside of a college teaching opportunity again.

Monday, May 26, 2014

Doing the Politics


The University of Texas football team hosted the Texas A & M squad the same weekend in the mid-1990's the Association for Experiential Education was in Austin making my first visit to the State capital a real blast. Yep, Austin is a college town, and holy longhorn, I felt at home with all the young adults parading along Congress, ambling up Guadalupe and careening 6th Street side to side. (A & M won, by the way.) There was a lot to experience that weekend: the history of Texas, the night-life of our host city, challenge courses in schools and experiential pedagogy in academic classes. But, the single most salient happening resonating the deepest in me then was the consistent chorus from the alternative school folks there: Do the Politics.


Collectively it was said: new private schools always need friends in public places; however, the need of friends in public places is far greater for new alternative private schools than for conventional schools; further, new alternative private schools serving special needs children require an even greater representation.


First off, as I recall the alternative school folks saying, friends are truly needed in Municipal, and even County and State, government to reduce opposition to the project by convincing other public officials that the need for the education service outweighs any prior tax revenue from the property on which the school is to occupy and from the sales the school undertakes-remember, schools are non-profit, tax exempt organizations and, especially, a school purchased property will remove it from the tax rolls. Additionally, friends could assure an intended school siting meets local land-use and zoning requirements, especially if variances are necessary.


Friends could intercede with the various commercial and residential community interests to ease any potential friction siting may create. Further, as most folks tend to be afraid of anything “alternative” and anyone labeled “special needs”, friends accepting the unconventional education philosophy and practice and the efficacy of the alternative in helping special needs children could do a great deal to demystify the school, its students and the education processes the school uses significantly lowering barriers to community acceptance. And, of course, if there is a spot of bother, friends can mediate, restoring good feelings between the community and the school. Implied in the advice of making friends in public places-at least I was hearing it-was the strong suggestion that friends would connect the school to the money folks who donate to various local charities and, of course, to the political friends. 
 

So, with the onset of summer 2004, in anticipation of initial community outreach in the very near future, I journeyed through the representative politics of my communities to find some friends for the concept, such as it was then, and me. I ended up with Lew M. Simon, Queens County Democratic
Party Leader for Part B of the 23rd Assembly District which encompassed my Breezy Point. In Queens, District Leaders have several important duties, such as selecting County candidates for local elected offices and endorsing candidates for City & State-Wide and National offices. But, in actuality, these vote outcomes are preordained in that the County Executive Committee selects and the County Leaders do what is expected of them. The real work of District Leaders is to assure the required signatures on election petitions placing the County selected candidates on the election day ballot and fully help support County operations by attending all County fund-raisers. Lew Simon does his Leadership duties and has consistently collected the highest number of petition signatures in the County. However, he looks to be the old ward healer, interceding with City powers to help resolve individual constituent problems in exchange for their votes and other favors. 
 

The good here is that over the years he has actually helped many, including us, to resolve as much as possible City government connected problems, but the bad is that the situations on which he cares to work are calculated to garner the obligations of those he helps. He puts the favors in his pocket redeeming them at his leisure for free goods and services and for votes when he runs to maintain his Leadership and when he has sought election to the City Council. But, if he sees a situation holding no prospect of obligation, he will ignore the constituent's plea for help. If this cynicism wasn't enough, he has what I call a learned ignorance being bothered never to know anything about municipal operations other than who to call with what City government problem, which is to my mind okay as far as it goes but it rarely goes far enough, especially when dealing with community-wide problems, such as local school district issues, mass transportation, road repair, land use issues and the like. 

Indeed, he never engages in finding solutions to community-wide issues because he has no personal interest in any; rather, he favors stoking constituent grievance as much because it relieves him of any responsibility to know anything substantive as much because he believes it brings him votes when he runs for elected office. There are many other really not-too-good aspects of Mr. Simon's personality, including verbally abusing-and I mean really debasing-those working with him, those he feels are against him-which are legion in number-and everyone in City agency leadership positions. He is foul-mouthed, selfish to the extreme and immensely self-absorbed. 
 

I was willing to put up with all of this-until November, 2013-for the access to folks in City government and in local party politics he provided who might befriend my school project and me. From the very beginning he said for me to forget about the school; and over the years he did not lift a finger to be a friend of the school project keeping to his uncaring sentiment to forget the project entirely. However, working with him allowed me enormous access to the Queens Borough President's office and the City's Department of Education, especially when I was looking to go the State Charter School route with Rockaway College. 
 

However, the most beneficial introduction was to our then City Councilman, Joseph P. Addabbo, Jr. The more Mr. Simon took me around to the many community meetings, the more the City Councilman and I talked with each other; over time the many conversations became a base for a friendship good enough for me to begin a quiet approach to Twice-Exceptionality and the total lack of education service for these children. The piecemeal approach of mini-conversations at meetings became insufficient for him, so very early in 2008 the City Councilman asked me to write a paper outlining the issues and recommending solutions. This I delivered to him May 8th. While I mentioned that neither Federal or New York State Education Law excluded direct education service to twice-exceptional children if a school district wishes to identify these youngsters and provide appropriate service to them, the complete absence of it throughout the State, including New York City, and the absence of any indication of a single thought to even say these children exist strongly made the point that only changes in State law could remedy the situation. I called for State legislation recognizing the existence of Twice-Exceptional pupils and for ordering the State Department of Education to insist each local district devise identification schemes and appropriate programs. He accepted the paper, understood the issues and agreed with the recommendations. But as City Councilman he said he could do little more than pass it on to our local State representatives. He did.

And then he ran to unseat the incumbent State Senator later that year. He won and in early 2009, he said for me to write the legislation working with his Legislative Director to polish the language. The new State Senator did not have a definite time-line; so I took my time. Indeed, I wanted to get it right. I put together a kind of advisory writing committee which would steer me in getting it right. The folks responding to my requests could not have been more expert and more generous in sharing their expertise, time and advice. On the ad hoc group were Melissa Sornik, Lois Baldwin, Kris Berman, Wendy Eisner, Susan Baum, Christy Folsom and Miriam Cherkes-Julkowski.

Working with Frank Scaduto, Senator Addabbo's Legislative Director, the bill was finished. It does what we wanted to do: recognizes Twice-Exceptional children as a distinct category of pupil requiring teaching/learning different from the mainstream and according to Twice-Exceptional characteristics, instructs the State Department of Education to insist local school districts and to help local school districts to establish identification procedures and appropriate education programs, and establishes a State-Wide advisory council supervising it all.

The Senate bill and its Assembly companion were originally introduced into the State Legislature in 2010, re-introduced in 2011, and reintroduced in 2013 as S1875 and A1522. Unfortunately, the economic state of New York placed barriers in the way of the accomplishing State mandates in mainstream education no less than those of special education. As Assemblywoman Cathy Nolan, Chair of the Assembly Education Committee, has said to me on more than one occasion: there isn't enough money to fund regular education...And you want me to create a mandate and funding for yet another special group?! Late last year, 2013, State Senator Addabbo modified the language of these bills to include funding for regular education. Frankly, I went a little crazy as I saw the changes as yet another way to screw the Twice-Exceptional while seeming to be doing right by them. But, Sen. Addabbo calmed me down by saying the inclusion of regular education funding in the bills was an inducement for Assemblywoman Nolan to look favorably on the bill. Having been told by the Education Committee Chair that she was very disinclined to agree with the sentiments in the bill, I have to wonder if even these inducements will work. But, our good State Senator and his legislative colleagues co-sponsoring the bills continue to work to get them considered and passed into Law.

In the end, Doing the Politics accomplished little on the ground. Yes, there is the legislation, but it remains stuck...going no where fast. And, yes, the access to the powers that be in the Queens Borough President's office and, more especially, in the City's Department of Education ultimately enabled me to intimately understand the processes, procedures and personalities in the City's drive to re-structure its schooling. And the access to local civic leaders and elected officials provided me insights into the issues, politics and governance of municipalities, and, particularly, of our local area. But, the expected connections, especially, with the money folks, to facilitate organizing and fund-raising my Rockaway College just did not happen.

Monday, May 19, 2014

Square Pegs, Solutions, Part 5


Hi, I’m Leo Fahey and I’m looking to start a school serving our square pegs. I've named it Sands College. Its Mission is to cultivate the intellectual gifts of the bright Learning Disabled youth from Breezy Point to Belle Harbor by providing them education environments dedicated to re-setting emotional and academic readiness to take responsibility for their own learning and to the exercise of that responsibility. These environments are to provide all youngsters individual and collective empowerment, mutual assistance and respect for individual interests, abilities and rates of social, cognitive and emotional growth. As I have pointed out, a sizable number of our bright children struggle daily. They possess ways of knowing at great odds with whom their present schools say they ought to be; their instinct to take responsibility for their studies, to learn in their own way, in their own time, is constantly surpressed. The cost of going against their instincts and trying to academically succeed using ways of knowing alien to who they are produce plummeting self-esteem, depression and learned helplessness leading to academic failure. Sands College would return to these bright youngsters the trust in their unique ways of knowing and the impulse to take responsibility for their course of study creating the conditions for academic success within each youngster.



Sands College would empower responsibility and academic success in four integrated levels representing a sequential growth from elementary education through junior college study. The levels are: The Primary School, The Venture Challenge, The Lower School and The Upper School. The Primary School uses an Open Classroom setting to establish a prepared environment. Children take responsibility for their learning as they engage the prepared environment through their unique interests, abilities and learning styles and collaborate with teachers in setting readiness and academic goals. The Venture Challenge, an intake personal growth program for the secondary education of The Lower School, creates community led outdoor adventure teams where youngsters take responsibility for trek organization and for the many outdoor chores necessary such as cooking and clean-up as well as land navigation and first-aid. The Lower School requires a high degree of personal responsibility as youngsters engage an intergrated curriculum through self-selected inquiry projects exploring Science, History, Arts, Letters, Performance and Foreign Language Arts and as each help others achieve individual learning goals. The Upper School enlists collective responsibility to create, maintain and facilitate Great Question explorations into the received knowledge coming from written tradition, Western and Eastern. Taking responsibility remains incomplete unless youngsters are empowered to manage their learning spaces. Sands College would employ a community governance model where youngsters and staff together make policy decisions at each developmental level and at the school-wide level. This is quite an abitious project, but all our children deserve all our best.



Feedback: 1) I want to thank Chris Stokes, President, Point Breeze Association, Donna Trotter, President, Roxbury Association, and Terry Cassidy, President, Rockaway Point Association, for allowing me to talk with their members at recent meetings. 2) I’m in the process of getting a meeting place for the first of a series of information/organization meetings to put Sands College together. The meeting will be in the evening on either September 20 or 27. Look for the announcement within the next week.

Square Pegs, Solutions, Part 4


“…it is the integrity and ‘gathering power’ of the pine tree that draws together language, science, mathematics, social studies, art, history, mythology, and on and on…This pine tree possesses…question[s]…It draws our attention…It evokes…It stands before us as a sign…From the pine tree, learn of the pine tree. But, also from the pine tree, learn of ourselves...this pine tree comes forward as the nesting point of a vast interconnecting network of relationships and it is the integrity of such a network which bestows integrity on the integrated curriculum.” (David W. Jardine, “On the Integrity of Things: Ecopedagogical Reflections on the Integrated Curriculum”, in “Current Concepts of Core Curriculum” from the National Association for Core Curriculum, p. 34) As the pine tree stands as a nesting point so also do things like tidal pools, cities, or spider webs and concepts like luminescence, alienation, or metaphor. These “themes” framing the curriculum stand as the immediate causes for secondary education inquiry: students would select from a community generated list one theme at any one time from which to develop a research question to concentrate inquiry. Early college students would also use a thematic curriculum but unlike the individuality of secondary education project study, early college study would be collective in seminars within a course structure equivalent to the rest of higher education and meant to satisfy common core university requirements.



The themes subject to seminar study are to be called “Great Questions”. An example of a Great Question might be, “What is the Eleventh Dimension?” This Great Question would examine the concepts of space from Euclidean to the mutliverse of String Theory. A second could be, “What is Nature?” This traces the changes in understanding from Aristotle to Einstein to present Gaian ecology. Taken together, Great Questions, emerging as a direct expression of the propriety, interest and necessity of the early college community itself, would launch explorations into the history, science, literature, sociology, political economies and philosophies of periods from Classical to Modern. Not to worry! Our older adolescent Square Pegs can do well with such heavy intellectual lifting. Leon Botstein, President of Bard College, argues in Jefferson’s Children that youngsters between the ages of sixteen and eighteen have reached a maturity where they need this kind of stimulation and challenge. Indeed, one witnesses such successful adolescent academic engagement in Simons Rock College of Bard in Great Barrington, Massachusetts, and in Bard High School Early College here in New York.



Feedback: 1) I’ve said to some that Fort Tilden could host these programs. I’ve since learned Gateway will only agree to a public school open to all NYC children. It becomes clear a venture meant to be a private not-for-profit, non-BPC affiliated endeavor, serving the children of the three communities of the Breezy Point Cooperative with the possibility of enrolling additional children from Neponsit and Belle Harbor cannot be at Fort Tilden. 2) There is a powerful resistance in the Coop to having any school here, I’ve learned. To those folks I plead: the youngsters in need in our three communities ought not to be denied their lives because there are no alternatives for them. And the plain, simple fact is that there are no suitable, alternative schools on the Peninsula, or in the rest of NYC for that matter! We pride ourselves as a community caring for its children, as most families are here to raise their children within the safety provided here. Then I say, let us demonstrate that commitment to their safety by dissolving the resistance in favor of the proactive support our children need.

Square Pegs, Solutions, Part 3


“The recovery time is proportionate to the hatred their last school gave them.”, A.S. Neil said on page 5 in his 1960 seminal book, Summerhill. This is true enough for our youngest square pegs, but it hits the center of the bull’s eye for our adolescents. Indeed, angry teenagers forced to accept academic work behave through their madness, as we have seen. Even placed in a special education class or transferred into another school, they continue to sabotage their own success. Thus, placing these angry youngsters directly into the academics of the scholastic program to be highlighted in this and the next article, which means to take bright, troubled adolescents through a combined high school and junior college experience with a diploma and an Associate‘s degree earned at the same time, without providing a time for healing, of taking off the pressure, would set these youngsters and the scholastic program itself for sure failure. These older children, like their younger brothers and sisters, need a time to reset their emotional and academic readiness. A mixed age, responsibility based outdoor education cooperative community program for age’s 12 and up would through team, trust and community building in outdoor activities such as camping, hiking and backpacking, greatly resolve feelings of failure and self-loathing, replacing them with growing feelings of success and self-worth, and would replace the internalized, oppressive norms of the uniform school with those of an empowering, responsibility based cooperative community culture preparing them for successful secondary academic study. More, working closely with each youngster would offer staff opportunities to understand the unique emotional and learning characteristics of each student and would enable them to assist in any remedial work necessary.



Youngsters when feeling confident and empowered would, then, move themselves into an ungraded, responsibility based, cooperative community secondary education academic program. This program would integrate the received knowledge coming from written tradition, Western and Eastern, into six general studies areas, Science, History, Letters, Arts, Performance and Foreign Language Arts, and place each branch of knowledge into a cooperative learning lab setting for concentrated study in the desired area. Intellectual curiosity and the natural differences in abilities, interests and communication style would drive student engagement with the learned world and participation in the learning labs rather than that of uniform, mandated curriculum and subject class assignments. Inquiry Project Based Learning and Performance Assessment would be used exclusively by students to acquire interdisciplinary skills and content knowledge. Projects would be developed, implemented and evaluated in the learning labs where group members act together to achieve individual project objectives. All students would have instructional staff mentors thoroughly versed in the cooperative, responsibility based academics of the secondary education program and in the unique cognitive styles of the school’s population to assist in setting and achieving personal and academic goals. And like their younger colleagues these youngsters would in community with staff take governance responsibility deciding such policy as project performance standards, or requirements for graduating secondary education students into the early college, or community norms and methods dealing with their violation. Indeed, this healing and empowering secondary education academic community is desperately needed for our bright teenage square pegs.   Look for an Information/Organization Meeting date coming soon to establish here the primary program and the secondary education early college as real brick and mortar.

Square Pegs, Solutions, Part 2


No parent is sure if their child will be turned into a square peg when kindergarten begins, although pre-school might give indications. But, if the uniform elementary school does its damage, then an immediate need arises for the child to be transferred into a learning environment re-setting emotional and academic foundations, restoring to the child his natural instincts to take responsibility for learning and his trust in his own way of knowing. An ungraded, open classroom, responsibility based learning community for children age’s five to eleven is well suited to do all that for our square pegs. And it fully satisfies the learning environment criteria set down last week.



First, it must be acknowledged that emotional readiness to accept a learning task comes well before the task. Forcing a task when a child feels angry, powerless or stupid, as do our square pegs, just frightens, discourages and deepens helplessness and failure. Formal learning re-setting emotional readiness to learn must provide a time for healing, a time of taking off the pressure, of reassurance, as in time our children will gain the energy and the courage to accept any task. As sustained, self-selected imaginative play is the best means of taking off the pressure, of providing a healing time, the open classroom, accordingly, would provide suitable spaces with lots of materials like Lincoln Logs and blocks, games and puzzles, sand and water tables, costumes and theatrical makeup, paints and crayons, newsprint and paper, books and magazines, etc. There would be performance spaces and kitchens, store/home props and appliances. There would also be indoor/outdoor playgrounds. Children would engage in imaginative activity, individual or group, organized or ad hoc, self or staff initiated, for as long as they wish. Although principally intended to re-set emotional readiness these activities re-set academic readiness as well in that such activities as block building, cooking/baking, exchanging play currency, drawing/painting, acting, even shooting baskets, tap applications in Geometry, Arithmetic Functions, Measurement, Chemistry, Physics, Language, among others, providing children an experiential base from which to build their academics. Children feeling ready would, then, engage the resources of the Academic Stations which would center on the learning skills of Literacy, Language and Calculation and in subjects of Earth, Space and Life Sciences, History and Geography. Teachers working closely with each child would help each develop readiness and academic goals.



Although the course of elementary study would be individualized to each child, as each engages the open classroom through his distinctive interests, abilities and learning styles, a common goal for all would be the development of competency in receiving, processing and communicating written, oral, graphic and numerical information re-setting academic readiness for secondary education. These competencies would emerge through a need to gain additional tools to explore more of the academic resource rich open classroom than through mandated mastery on or before a time or an age certain. And, finally, children have the capacity to fully participate in school governance and along with staff make policy for their community. Community norms as well as methods dealing with their violation, or graduation requirements allowing youngsters to pass out from the primary program are examples of policy items determined by staff and students together. Indeed, this healing and empowering primary school environment is desperately needed for our youngest square pegs.